Just When You Think Settlement is Near...Beware the Equal Credit Opportunity Act!

March 6, 2019

View Full Article

By Deborah S. Lapin 
 
When one thinks about the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (the “ECOA”) in the lending context, one immediately envisions consumer complaints related to discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status or age in the mortgage origination process. However, ECOA on its face also prohibits discrimination against a borrower/applicant that has “exercised a right” under the Consumer Credit Protection Act in which TILA is found. In other words, ECOA may prohibit discrimination against a borrower for exercising a TILA claim.
 
In the litigation context, an “exercised right” triggering an ECOA claim may arise during settlement discussions wherein, as a condition of settlement, a borrower is asked to dismiss a TILA claim. Arguably, a litigious borrower could allege (and note, actually has alleged) discrimination under ECOA by being asked to dismiss an “exercised right.”
 
Fortunately, “exercised rights” ECOA claims are defendable based on the definitions contained in the statute, particularly the definition of “discriminate against an applicant” which means “to treat an applicant less favorably than other applicants.” Discrimination is difficult for a borrower to prove in the context of a settlement proposal in a lawsuit given the fact that, unlike the origination process, there is not a readily identifiable pool of similarly situated applicants against which purported discrimination may be measured.
 
Although this blurb is based on a couple of anecdotal experiences and is not exhaustive, defense counsel in the mortgage industry should keep on the lookout for litigation settlement based ECOA claims and remember that what, at first blush may sound like a compelling theory from plaintiff, is likely a red herring.

 

Visit the Mortgage Industry Must-Knows Blog 
 

 

By Deborah S. Lapin, Esq.
(248) 208-0709 direct | dlapin@maddinhauser.com
Maddin, Hauser, Roth & Heller, P.C.
28400 Northwestern Highway, Second Floor Essex Centre
Southfield, Michigan 48034-1839 | 248 354 4030 phone
Visit Firm Website | Visit Firm Law Firm Alliance profile

This article is for general information only and should not be used as a basis for specific action without obtaining further legal advice.